Tuesday, January 14, 2020

Think Tank CAP to Create Foreign Policy "Master Plan" for 2021

Democratic think tanks are pulling out their pens and papers as they furiously try to write game plans for a possible Democratic president should Republican Donald Trump lose the 2020 election.

Here is more from Axios:
The Center for American Progress tomorrow (Jan. 14) will convene prominent Obama administration alumni to create a foreign-policy "master plan" for what they hope will be an incoming Democratic president in 2021.  CAP says the conference will feature Ambassador Samantha Power, Ambassador Susan Rice, Denis McDonough, Michèle Flournoy, Avril Haines, Jake Sullivan and more.

Democratic think tanks have largely been sidelined during the Trump presidency, and many scholars from the Obama era and Clinton era are housed within those policy shops.

Update: Here is a list of 11 advisers, including think tankers, shaping candidates' climate policies.

Monday, January 13, 2020

Think Tank Quickies (#368)

  • The American Conservative (TAC) holds panel entitled "Think Tank Town: The Swampy Ecosystem Supporting Status Quo."
  • Gender gaps at think tanks.
  • Pic: Not sure why we need think tanks.
  • How China cultivates Europe's policy think tanks.
  • Pic: RAND Corp. releases 2020 calendar.
  • Claremont Institute recognized by White House.
  • Think tanks being challenged in many countries with fake news and alternative facts.
  • OxyContin's delayed the reckoning for their role in the opioid crisis by funding think tanks.
  • Bloomberg Law: Facebook, Google funding think tanks to shape federal policy debate.

Thursday, January 9, 2020

Sen. Tom Cotton Attacks New Anti-War Think Tank

Here is more from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency:

Sen. Tom Cotton accused the Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft, a new think tank funded by the billionaires George Soros and Charles Koch, of fostering anti-Semitism in speech on the Senate floor on Wednesday.
Cotton, R-Ark., referred to anti-Semitism as an “ancient hatred” and referenced recent attacks against Jews in Brooklyn and Monsey.
“[Anti-Semitism] festers in Washington think tanks like the Quincy Institute, an isolationist blame America first money pit for so-called ‘scholars’ who’ve written that American foreign policy could be fixed if only it were rid of the malign influence of Jewish money,” he said in remarks quoted prior to the speech by Jewish Insider.
The institute’s list of affiliated experts includes some figures who have at times been accused by mainstream Jewish groups of crossing from political commentary on Israel into anti-Semitism, such as political scientist John Mearsheimer, author of “The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy.” No evidence ties any of the experts affiliated with Quincy to the recent rise in anti-Semitic attacks.

More about the Quincy Institute can be found here.

Tuesday, January 7, 2020

North Korean Hackers Target Think Tanks

Here is more from Reuters:

Microsoft Corp said on Monday it has taken control of web domains which were used by a hacking group called “Thallium” to steal information.
Thallium is believed to be operating from North Korea, Microsoft said in a blog post, and the hackers targeted government employees, think tanks, university staff members and individuals working on nuclear proliferation issues, among others.
Most of the targets were based in the United States, as well as Japan and South Korea, the company said.

North Korea has been hacking into think tanks around the world for years.  Here is an example from 2013.  Another of other countries have also been accused of hacking into think tanks, including China and Russia.

Monday, January 6, 2020

Fox News Host Tucker Carlson Sharply Criticizes Heritage Foundation

Here is more from The Hill:

The conservative Heritage Foundation pushed back on Fox News host Tucker Carlson on Saturday after he sharply criticized the organization during a segment on tech policy.
Carlson blasted the foundation and other groups during his show Friday night, arguing that Beltway conservative organizations have "colluded with big tech to shield left-wing monopolies from any oversight."
In specifically going after Heritage, where Carlson used to work, the host asserted, "As an organization, Heritage no longer represents the interests of conservatives, at least on the question of tech."

In response to Carlson, Heritage issued a statement saying that the Fox News host "made several false, outrageous, and unfounded accusations" against the think tank.

Here is the Washington Examiner's reporting on the incident.  Newsweek says that the rebuke of Heritage drew more than three million viewers.

Wikipedia notes that Carlson began his journalism career as a fact-checker for Policy Review, a national conservative journal then published by the Heritage Foundation and eventually acquired by the Hoover Institution.  Its final issue date was in 2013.

Thursday, January 2, 2020

Think Tank Quickies (#367)

  • A mealtime guide to DC think tanks.
  • The think tank dedicated to keeping the US in Syria.
  • Large police presence at Heritage Foundation for Andy Ngo speech.
  • Roosevelt Institute at Cornell University joins UK student think tank to tackle global issues.
  • CGTN think tank launches in Beijing.
  • Florida State University now home to one of the US's only student-run think tanks.
  • Economic Innovation Groups spars with ProPublica over Opportunity Zones.
  • What is a think tank? A French perspective.
  • Huge pro-India fake news network includes Canadian sites, links to Canadian think tanks.
  • "DC think tank report or Bachelor's-level international relations paper" is a fun game to play.
  • Tip for people designing webpages for think tanks (hint: make it simple!).

Friday, December 6, 2019

Liberty University Launches Its Own Think Tank

Here is more from The News & Advance:

Liberty University has added a new institution to its ever-expanding campus: a think tank.
The school announced Saturday the launch of the Falkirk Center for Faith and Liberty, which aims to shape government policies, national institutions and American culture around Judeo-Christian principles.
The center is the brainchild of Liberty University President Jerry Falwell Jr. and Charlie Kirk, the founder and executive director of Turning Point USA, a conservative youth organization with close ties to U.S. President Donald Trump.
The nonprofit Falkirk Center, which is named after its co-founders, will operate as a wholly-owned subsidiary of Liberty University and will be based in Lynchburg. The center is funded by the university, which boasts an endowment of nearly $1.5 billion, according to a financial audit released by the school. A director has not yet been named.
Erika Lane Frantzve, a former Miss Arizona USA winner; Josh Allen Murray, a former contestant on “The Bachelorette;” Antonia Okafor Cover, the spokesperson for Gun Owners of America; David J. Harris Jr., a conservative author; and Jaco Booyens, a conservative filmmaker, have all been named as the center’s first fellows.
In addition to the fellows, more than 60 “ambassadors” have joined the project to educate high school and college-age students about the “inseparable intersection of the Gospel of Jesus Christ and American first freedoms and liberties” through social media, Kirk said in an interview Tuesday.

A number of think tanks in the US are housed within colleges and universities, although only a handful advocate for policies from a conservative religious position.

Monday, December 2, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#366)

  • Spotted at the Hudson Institute's annual Herman Kahn Award dinner: Rupert Murdoch, Jerry Hall, Donald Trump Jr. and Kimberly Guilfoyle, Chris Wallace, and many others.
  • Heather Nauert is joining the Hudson Institute as a senior fellow focusing on foreign policy.
  • 133 foreign policy officials, including think tankers, endorse Joe Biden.
  • More than 650 Clinton campaign and administration alum came together at their 4th reunion at USIP.
  • Nearly 200 FBI investigations into stolen research by Chinese underway at major academic centers in US.
  • Meet a think tank: The Institute of Alcohol Studies (IAS).
  • Leaders of a Beautiful Struggle (LBS): A think tank focused on public policy advocacy for Baltimore's black residents. 
  • Joseph Overton created his legacy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy: the "Overton Window."
  • Gustav Gressel at ECFR published a report on how Germany ignored the interests of its EU neighbors and Ukraine to force through the controversial Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline deal with Russia.  Within hours, Miguel Berger at the German foreign ministry took to Twitter demanding an apology. 
  • Will Tanner, director of the center-right Onward think tank, made a contribution to the British political lexicon: "Workington Man."

Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Think Tank Scholar Being Sued by Huawei

Here is more from Bloomberg:

Huawei Technologies Co. is suing critics in France who alleged it has ties to the Chinese state.
In an unprecedented move, the technology giant filed three defamation claims in Paris over comments made during television programs by a French researcher, a broadcast journalist and a telecommunications sector expert.
Valerie Niquet, a researcher at the Paris-based Foundation for Strategic Research that specializes in China and Japan, is a regular guest on French radio and television. Huawei filed the lawsuit after her comments in two television programs in February in which she said the company had ties to the state.
Niquet was informed of the claims in September and then in November when the police reached out to her to confirm her comments, according to copies of the authorities’ emails seen by Bloomberg.

This is the first case that Think Tank Watch is aware of where a think tanker has been sued by a corporation for commentary.

A think tank teamed up with a scholar recently found that around 100 Huawei employees had education or work experience linked to Chinese military or intelligence agencies.

Last year, it was reported that Huawei paid the Brookings Institution to write favorable reports.

Sunday, November 24, 2019

Think Tank FDD Starts Sister Lobbying Arm

Here is more from Politico:

Tyler Stapleton, the Foundation for Defense of Democracies’ deputy director of congressional relations, has registered to lobby through FDD Action. It’s the first time the think tank has had a registered lobbyist. Stapleton will lobby on a variety of bills involving Turkey and Iran — of which the think tank has been sharply critical — and Israel, which the think tank has defended.

Here is more on the announcement from Al-Monitor.

Iran recently sanctioned FDD, a think tank that may have contributed to the destruction of the Iran nuclear deal.

A number of other Washington think tanks have sister lobbying arms, including the conservative Heritage Foundation and the liberal Center for American Progress (CAP).

Here is a Think Tank Watch piece on a new strategy that lobbyists have on increasing their outreach to think tanks in 2020.

Thursday, November 21, 2019

New 2020 Lobbying Strategy: Deeper Outreach to Think Tanks

Here is more from Roll Call:

It’s hard to imagine a more bonkers, unpredictable and politically toxic backdrop for K Street operators than the current one. But just wait until 2020 actually arrives. 
The presidential election year will hit lobbyists with potential risks all around. Candidates up and down the ballot will press proposals to remake the influence industry and to overhaul the nation’s campaign finance system. More candidates will reject K Street and business donations. The approaching elections, along with an expected impeachment trial early on, will turn Capitol Hill into an even bigger political mess.
Still, lobbyists say they have no plans to zip up their campaign checkbooks, hide under their desks or decamp from the capital.
Instead, they’re brewing alternative strategies, workarounds that include deeper outreach to think tanks, academia and other institutions that can lend policy gravitas to shape major discussions over health care, immigration, trade, taxes and other matters that will feature prominently on the campaign trail and beyond.

Lobbyists and lobbying firms have ramped up outreach to think tanks over the years, making thousands of contacts at Washington, DC-area think tanks large and small each year.  In turn, think tanks often lobby the executive and legislative branches.

Foreign governments have also been hiring lobbying firms for help with outreach to think tanks.

Monday, November 18, 2019

New White Paper: Russia's Use of Pseudo-Think Tanks

The Stanford Internet Observatory has just published a new white paper on the online operations of the GRU, the main military foreign-intelligence service of Russia, highlighting pseudo-think tanks and personas.

Here is a clip from the report:

The GRU narrative strategy also involved the creation of think tanks and “alternative news” sites to serve as initial content drops, from which the content was syndicated or republished on other sites. These think tanks and media sites relied on personas —fake online identities that persist over time, or across multiple platforms, and attempt to create a perception that the person behind the identity is real—who served as both bylined authors for the GRU’s own fabricated media properties and “freelancers” who could inject the narrative into other publications under the guise of contributing authors. The content-creator personas served as both authors and amplifiers, often cross-promoting each other’s articles. In addition, we found a network of highly suspicious, likely fabricated accounts who were involved in the distribution of the content on other social platforms, including Twitter and Reddit.

Here is a recent Think Tank Watch post about a new think tank helping Russia gain influence in Africa.

Here is a previous Think Tank Watch piece on the Russian Institute for Strategic Studies (RISS), a think tank that has been accused of trying to sway the 2016 US presidential election.

Here is a piece on deepfake think tank scholars.

Thursday, November 7, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#365)

  • Why we should stop treating peer review as the gold standard of research.
  • More scientific papers should be retracted; prank jabs at academic papers; broken system lets doctors omit industry ties in journals.
  • Kiron Skinner, who recently took leave as a researcher at the Hoover Institution to serve in the Trump Administration, forced out as State Department's director of policy planning.
  • Can you publish virtually anything in scientific journals? Predatory publisher fined $50 million. 
  • Let policy wonks proliferate: Xi Jinping is encouraging a boom in "independent" Chinese think tanks.
  • North Korea Strategy Center (NKSC): a Seoul-based think tank founded by a North Korean defector.
  • DC bucket lists overflow with think tank desires?
  • Brookings scholars Carol O'Cleireacain and Alice Rivlin had pushed for DC population growth.
  • Wealthy businessmen such as textile magnate Roger Milliken funded anti-globalization studies and think tanks; former Chrysler CEO Lee Iacocca funded Clyde Prestowitz's Economic Strategy Institute.

Wednesday, November 6, 2019

"Gold-Spoon" Favoritism and South Korean Think Tanks

Here is more from the New York Times:

In South Korea, white-collar workers’ salaries and job titles in their 60s can often be predicted by which university they attended. The jostling for position starts in kindergarten, with some rich parents spending thousands of dollars a month on private tutoring to help their children secure spots in elite prep schools and top universities.
Well-connected families often resort to dubious tactics to get their children into the best universities, such as helping them land coveted internships at big corporations, research think tanks and university labs, which offer opportunities to get credit on research papers.
The Education Ministry’s audits of universities since 2017 have uncovered 794 research papers where middle school or high school students were listed as co-authors, including at least 11 where professors named their own children as co-authors. When economists from Seoul National University compared two boroughs of Seoul in 2014, they found that children from the wealthier borough were 20 times more likely to enter the university, the country’s most coveted, than children from the other.

According to the University of Pennsylvania, there are 60 think tanks in South Korea.  According to UPenn, the country's top-ranked think tank is Korea Development Institute (KDI), ranked 20th in the world.

Tuesday, November 5, 2019

World Bank Worked With Chinese Think Tank on Policy Blueprint

Here is more from the Economist:

In a new report the World Bank has made its own contribution to Chinese numerology, introducing the “three Ds”. These, it says, refer to what China must do to become more productive and innovative: remove economic distortions, diffuse technology and foster discovery.
The World Bank has more experience than most in this, having loaned cash (more than $60bn) and expertise to China over nearly four decades. Its report, “Innovative China”, published on September 17th, reflects a slightly different approach. It is the third time since 2012 that it has jointly written a policy blueprint with the Development Research Centre, a think-tank under the State Council. It is, in theory, a way to put recommendations into the prime minister’s hands, and perhaps into the next five-year plan.
This report came with more controversy than the previous two.  In March the Washington Post reported that it had been ready for a year, but that Chinese authorities had blocked its release because they objected to some of its contents, notably a section on reforming state-owned enterprises.

Here is a link to the above-mentioned Washington Post story, and here is a link to the new report jointly written by the World Bank and China's Development Research Center (DRC).

Monday, November 4, 2019

New Think Tank Helping Russia Gain Influence in Africa

Here is more from the New York Times:

Mr. [Jose] Matemulane runs a think tank called Afric, which describes itself on its website as “funded by donors with a common passion to foster Africa’s development,” without mentioning Russia. In an interview, though, Mr. Matemulane said the group was launched last year with support from a St. Petersburg businessman he declined to name.
Afric received prominent billing at a summit for dozens of African leaders hosted by President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia at the Black Sea resort of Sochi last week, and announced it would partner with a Russian propaganda specialist who had previously focused on the United States.
It also drew the notice of Mamadou Koulibaly, a candidate for president of Ivory Coast in elections next year.
“I will ask them if they can introduce me to people with money who will help me,” Mr. Koulibaly said of Afric. “This is important. A campaign needs money.”
Afric — an acronym for Association for Free Research and International Cooperation — is building ties with African politicians and commentators while publishing articles that extol the benefits of cooperating with Russia. It has also invested heavily in election monitoring missions that mirror Russia’s approach in its own elections: bringing in sympathetic foreigners who praise the votes’ fairness and transparency, even as established Western organizations criticize them.

The article goes on to note that investigative journalists have reported that Afric is funded by Yevgeny Prigozhin, who was indicted by the US for running the "troll farm" that sought to sway the 2016 US presidential election.  Afric employees deny any connection.

In July, a Russian think tank with links to an infamous troll farm said two of its employees were detained in Libya.

Here is a 2017 report on Russian think tanks and soft power from the Swedish Defense Research Agency.

Friday, November 1, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#364)

  • Mike Pence delivers major China speech at Wilson Center's inaugural Frederic M. Malek Public Service Leadership Lecture; SecState Mike Pompeo slams China at Hudson speech.
  • Atlantic Council's Global 2035 report featured in top spot on Axios AM; says era of American dominance is "definitely over."
  • MapLight: Facebook, Google, and Amazon pour money into think tanks.
  • Economic Innovation Group: A Washington think tank that studies regional inequality and pushes for policies that combat it. 
  • Video: Lee Fang asks Heartland Institute president about past smoking claims. 
  • Working at a think tank to relax: "Jonathan Wong worked 80-hour weeks in management consulting...it was hard to take a break so he moved to a job at the RAND Corp. and took a 30 percent pay cut."
  • New Consensus: A think tank with ties to progressive lawmakers.
  • Newish think tank: Washington Institute for Business, Government and Society.  Its founder/CEO is James Moore Jr., a former assistant secretary of Commerce.  It has partnerships with BDO, Oxford Analytica, Wall Street Journal's CEO Council, and WP Live, among others.
  • Perks at R Street Institute: unlimited PTO, can work from wherever they need, $1,200/yr. for wellness, $3,000/yr. for student loan repayments, $400 towards a new phone, and $40/mo. toward cell phone service.
  • Colorado's think tanks put ideas into action.

Thursday, October 31, 2019

Think Tank CEI Lobbying to Weaken Dishwasher Regulations

Who knew that think tanks have become dishwasher lobbyists?

Here is more from the New York Times:
The Washington-based Competitive Enterprise Institute, a group that disputes that climate change is a problem, has promoted the effort to roll back dishwasher regulations, filing a petition that directly prompted the dishwasher review. As a nonprofit organization, the Competitive Enterprise Institute isn’t required to disclose its donors, though a recent gala organized by the institute showed that the institute counts among its donors groups that have long been aligned with fossil fuel interests.

The Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI) has deep ties to the Trump Administration and has been extremely influential the past couple of years in helping roll back various US regulations.

Here is a recent Think Tank Watch post about Google defending its funding of the think tank. Here is more about CEI's donors.

Wednesday, October 30, 2019

Paul Ryan Launches New Think Tank

Here is more from The Hill:

Former Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) on Monday launched a nonprofit organization that will focus on his legislative priorities during his two decades in Congress: fighting poverty, boosting economic opportunity and promoting “evidence-based” reforms on issues like welfare, foster care and criminal justice.
The American Idea Foundation, which will have offices in his hometown of Janesville, Wis., will partner with community organizations, academics and lawmakers. Ryan will serve as president of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit.

Here is a link to the American Idea Foundation website.

Roll Call notes that Ryan has funded his new think tank largely through his political action committee (PAC).

The Washington Examiner notes that the think tank plans to partner with other think tanks to address poverty, drug addiction, education, upward mobility, and other reforms Ryan worked on in Washington.

In September, Ryan joined the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) as a Distinguished Visiting Fellow.

Monday, October 28, 2019

Milken Institute Influencing Treasury on Taxes, May Profit From It

Here is more from the New York Times:

In the 1980s, Michael Milken embodied Wall Street greed. A swashbuckling financier, he was charged with playing a central role in a vast insider-trading scheme and was sent to prison for violating federal securities and tax laws. He was an inspiration for the Gordon Gekko character in the film “Wall Street.”
Mr. Milken has spent the intervening decades trying to rehabilitate his reputation through an influential nonprofit think tank, the Milken Institute, devoted to initiatives “that advance prosperity.”
These days, the Milken Institute is a leading proponent of a new federal tax break that was intended to coax wealthy investors to plow money into distressed communities known as “opportunity zones.” The institute’s leaders have helped push senior officials in the Trump administration to make the tax incentive more generous, even though it is under fire for being slanted toward the wealthy.
Mr. Milken, it turns out, is in a position to personally gain from some of the changes that his institute has urged the Trump administration to enact. In one case, the Treasury secretary, Steven Mnuchin, directly intervened in a way that benefited Mr. Milken, his longtime friend.

Think Tank Watch recently reported that the Milken Institute is opening a Washington, DC branch that will be the closest think tank to the White House.  The Times reports that Milken's family spent more than $85 million to buy three buildings opposite the White House and Treasury Department for the DC office.

Friday, October 25, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#363)

  • US State Dept. now requiring Chinese diplomats to notify US authorities before meetings at US research institutions. 
  • Vice President Mike Pence headlines first-ever Heritage Honors gala; Secretary of State Mike Pompeo delivers remarks at Heritage Foundation.
  • The Koch Foundation is influencing foreign policy with think tanks.
  • Think tank CEI compiles decades worth of dire climate predictions.
  • Inside Aspen Institute's Executive Seminar: the mountain retreat for the liberal elite.
  • Washingtonian piece on Open Markets Institute. 
  • Leslie Gelb, former president of the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), dies.
  • LSE IDEAS event: Think tanks and their role in the age of digital and political disruption. 
  • Think tank writer temporarily suspended by Twitter because of Turkish troll campaign?
  • Hybrid Analytica: Pro-Kremlin expert propaganda in Russia, Europe, and the US - a case study of think tanks and universities.

Wednesday, October 23, 2019

JPMorgan Chase Starts New Policy Center in DC

Here is more from Fortune:
JPMorgan today is announcing several major steps to encourage second-chance hiring for those with criminal records. The bank is officially "banning the box"—removing all questions about criminal records from its job applications. It will steer more than $7 million toward organizations that provide job- and life-skills training to the formerly incarcerated. The bank is also launching a new “policy center,” a think tank of sorts that will design and advocate for regulatory changes around certain economic issues. Its first agenda item: reforming rules that effectively bar former felons from employment, in finance and elsewhere.

The new think tank, JPMorgan Chase PolicyCenter (website here), will be run by Heather Higginbottom, a former US Deputy Secretary of State under President Barack Obama.  She is also a founder and former executive director of national security think tank American Security Project (ASP).

In 2015, JPMorgan launched a think tank (JPMorgan Chase Institute) dedicated to delivering data-rich analysis and expert insights for the public good.

Tuesday, October 22, 2019

Inside Stephen Miller's Secret Think Tank

Here is more from Axios:
Stephen Miller "was running a sort of secret immigration think tank out of the West Wing," the N.Y. Times' Julie Davis and Mike Shear report in "Border Wars: Inside Trump's Assault on Immigration," out Tuesday.

An excerpt from the book says that the group, which usually met on Fridays, was part of "a quiet but methodical effort...to seize control of the machinery of government and use it to make good on the president's immigration agenda."

As Think Tank Watch has previously noted, Miller is likely the largest consumer of think tank reports in the entire White House.

Here is a previous post about another internal White House think tank in the Trump era.

Monday, October 21, 2019

New Report Documents UAE's Deep Ties to Think Tanks

The Center for International Policy's (CIP) Foreign Influence Transparency Initiative (FITI) has published a new report showing the United Arab Emirates' (UAE) deep connection to US think tanks.

Among other things, the report found that UAE foreign agents had contacted 200 congressional offices, 18 think tanks, and most mainstream media outlets in 2018. Those 18 think tanks were contacted a total of 85 different times last year (and that is just contacts that were reported).

The top five think tanks most contacted by UAE foreign agents were:
  1. Washington Institute for Near East Policy (WINEP): 18
  2. Middle East Institute (MEI): 14
  3. Center for American Progress (CAP): 11
  4. American Enterprise Institute (AEI): 10
  5. Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS): 5

The report says that UAE foreign agents "directed their efforts towards some of the most prominent and influential think tanks in D.C. and towards experts at think tanks the UAE was directly or indirectly funding."  In turn, the report added, "UAE foreign agents often help to distribute the work of these experts at think tanks the UAE is funding."

Over the past year, there has also been a significant effort to track Saudi influence at US think tanks.

Sunday, October 20, 2019

Fake Tinder Profiles Used by NATO Think Tank to Test Ranks

Here is more from EURACTIV:

When NATO’s Centre for Strategic Communication in Riga discovered how easy it was to dupe its soldiers online, it has started looking for ways of countering false information, which comes, in large part, from Russia.
On Tinder, a popular dating app, some even communicated with a woman, sending pictures of themselves in uniform. One evening, two soldiers even arranged to meet the virtual woman. They both left their post for her, a move which proved to be a mistake.
The website for soldiers and the Tinder profile was tested by a group of men and women in a low-rise building in Riga, in NATO’s Centre for Strategic Communication, which is supported by Germany.
Janis Sarts, who previously worked for the Latvian defence ministry, is now leading a group of 50 people in the NATO centre, which analyses disinformation campaigns, also called ‘Fake News’.

Here is the website for the NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence (NATO StratCom COE), which became functional in January 2014.

The think tank has run a similar operation using Facebook and Instagram.

A number of foreign governments have been using fake LinkedIn profiles (including fake think tank experts) to lure legitimate think tankers and others into spying for them.

Saturday, October 19, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#362)

  • Think tanks give support for President Trump impeachment probe. 
  • Len Blavatnik and the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR).
  • Center for Public Integrity: Inside the shadowy think tank pushing to kick 3.1 million people off food stamps.
  • American Prospect: Washington's "freedom promoting" think tanks that ignore Jamal Khashoggi's murder.
  • Think tanks behind the climate denial movement.
  • Bruce Bartlett: Right-wing think tanks no longer deny climate change, but they argue that the free market will fix it. 
  • Jared Yates Sexton: "The Republican Party used to get its principles and strategies from DC think tanks.  Now it comes from 4chan, 8chan..."
  • Parnell Palme McGuinness: Think tanks and the death of the power of ideas.
  • India's External Affairs Minister Jaishankar's 7-day, 7-think tank blitz in DC.
  • Energy think tank accuses Conservatives in Canada of misusing their research in ad.
  • Robbie Jaeger: "Think tank is a polite way of saying a group of insiders and elites are going to start of 501c3/4 (often funded by 1%ers) and use back channel communications and funds to concoct narratives that coordinate and manipulate public perception.

Friday, October 18, 2019

Lobby Shop Will Help Congo With Outreach to Think Tanks

Here is more from Politico:
The Republic of the Congo has hired Michael Sullivan and Kimberly West of the Ashcroft Law Firm to lobby Congress and the Trump administration, work on "media outreach and strategy" and seek the support of thought leaders and think tanks, according to a Justice Department filing. Former Attorney General John Ashcroft, the firm's founder, hasn't registered to do any work for the country. The contract is worth $75,000 a month.

Foreign governments (as well as individuals and corporations) often pay think tanks both directly and indirectly (through lobbying firms, law firms, and consulting firms) to influence their work and help shape policy and perceptions.

Thursday, October 17, 2019

Bulgaria Charges Think Tanker With Spying for Russia

Here is more from Reuters:

A Bulgarian investigation into alleged espionage involving Russian non-governmental organizations is not intended to influence relations with Moscow, Prime Minister Boyko Borissov said on Wednesday.
Prosecutors charged the head of a Bulgarian non-governmental organization (NGO) on Tuesday with spying for Russia as part of a scheme they said aimed to draw Bulgaria away from its Western allies and towards Moscow.
Prosecutors said Nikolai Malinov, 50, head of the National Russophile Movement, had worked for the Russian Institute for Strategic Studies, run mainly by former foreign intelligence officials, and also for another Russian NGO, the Double-Headed Eagle, since 2010.

Here is a previous Think Tank Watch piece on the Russian Institute for Strategic Studies (RISS), a think tank that has been accused of trying to sway the 2016 US presidential election.  Malinov has been accused of accepting payments for transferring Bulgarian state secrets to RISS.

Among other things, Mr. Malinov was also accused of planning to create internet sites, a TV channel, an influential think tank, and a political party to encourage Bulgarians to form more positive views of Russia.

Wednesday, October 16, 2019

Goulard Gets Tripped Up With Connection to US Think Tank

Here is more from the New York Times:

The French nominee for a top European Union job was rejected by the European Parliament on Thursday, a stinging defeat for President Emmanuel Macron, who has been criticized for bypassing the continental legislature, even as his power has been growing within the bloc.
Sylvie Goulard, a former minister under Mr. Macron and a longtime member of the European Parliament, was rejected after grueling hearings at the hands of her former colleagues.
During her nomination hearings, other lawmakers also questioned the lucrative consulting work that she did for the Los Angeles-based Berggruen Institute, a research organization founded by the billionaire German-American investor Nicolas Berggruen, while she served in the European Parliament from 2013 to 2016. 

The Associated Press reports that Goulard was paid around $11,000 per month for her work at Berggruen.

Here is a previous Think Tank Watch post of the Berggruen Institute.

Tuesday, October 15, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#361)

  • Brookings releases new style guide with updates to racial and ethnic terms.
  • Buttigieg's white-paper cites a few think tanks, including CAP and Third Way.
  • Lee Fang: Think tank CSIS celebrates climate strike with ritzy event funded by BP.
  • Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse: Amazon should stop funding climate denying think tanks like CEI.
  • Andrea Baertl on think tanks and the private sector.
  • Pic: Working at the Urban Institute.
  • Modi's foreign minister's son sent to head newly opened DC branch of Indian think tank Observer Research Foundation (ORF).
  • Hewlett Foundation: Can African think tanks help strengthen gov't use of data and evidence?
  • ExxonMobil funding Democratic think tank Progressive Policy Institute (PPI).
  • ThinkProgress was always doomed?
  • Pic: Exclusive footage of scenes at certain Washington think tank over firing of John Bolton.

Monday, October 14, 2019

Google Defends Funding of Climate Change-Denying Think Tanks

Here is more from The Verge:

Google makes “substantial” donations to climate change-denying Washington think tanks, according to a new report from The Guardian on Friday. The revelation comes only a few weeks after Google announced its support for political action to fix the climate crisis.
Google contributes to conservative political organizations and lobbies that are in support of regulatory efforts that benefit the company. Defending the donations to organizations like the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI) that were cited in the report, Google said that it might not endorse every policy position of an organization when it makes a contribution.
“We’re hardly alone among companies that contribute to organisations while strongly disagreeing with them on climate policy,” a Google spokesperson told The Verge.
According to people at Google, The Guardian said that people at the company said that it makes these donations in hopes of influencing conservative lawmakers and pushing forward a deregulatory agenda, something that has become ever more important in recent months as Congress works to craft data privacy legislation.

Google funding is very important to many think tanks, and policy shops will often go out of their way to defend the search giant's contributions.

Update: Over 100 mothers and babies have blockaded Google's offices by staging a mass feed-in over their donations to climate deniers.

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

Volker Resigns as Head of McCain Institute

Here is more from Politico:

Kurt Volker, the president’s former special envoy to Ukraine, has stepped down from yet another post, his executive directorship of the McCain Institute, amid the fallout from House Democrats’ impeachment inquiry.
Volker resigned from his role at the State Department a little over a week ago, and his resignation as the head of the D.C.-based think tank came days after he appeared as Democrats’ first witness in their widening impeachment probe, turning over damaging text messages that appeared to undermine President Donald Trump’s claims that he did not seek to pressure Ukraine into investigating his political opponents.
In a statement released Monday announcing his departure, Volker specifically referenced the growing Ukraine scandal and the ensuing media frenzy. 
“Today, I informed ASU President Crow and Mrs. McCain that I believe the recent media focus on my work as U.S. Special Representative for Ukraine Negotiations risks becoming a distraction from the accomplishments and continued growth of the Institute, and therefore I am stepping down as Executive Director of the McCain Institute for International Leadership,” he said, referring to the wife of the late Sen. John McCain, for whom the think tank was founded, and the president of Arizona State University, which is a partner of the institute. 

Here is a previous Think Tank Watch post on Volker and the McCain Institute.

According to CNN, Volker told staff at the Institute last week that he had no plans to resign.

In a statement, Cindy McCain said the executive committee of the trustees has asked Fran Townsend to serve as trustee representative of the think tank to coordinate the transition to a new executive director.  In the meantime, Nick Rasmussen has been asked by ASU leadership to serve as acting executive director.

Friday, October 4, 2019

Atlantic Council Gets Tangled in Impeachment Probe

Here is an excerpt from Breitbart:

A staffer for Rep. Adam Schiff's House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence took a trip to Ukraine last month sponsored and organized by the Atlantic Council think tank.
The Atlantic Council is funded by and routinely works in partnership with Burisma, the natural gas company at the center of allegations regarding Joe Biden and his son, Hunter Biden.
The Schiff staffer, Thomas Eager, is also currently one of 19 fellows at the Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Congressional Fellowship, a bipartisan program that says it “educates congressional staff on current events in the Eurasia region.”
Eager’s trip to Ukraine last month was part of the fellowship program and included nine other House employees. The bi-partisan visit, from August 24 to August 31, was billed as a “Ukraine Study Trip,” and culminated in a meeting with former Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko.
The dates of the pre-planned trip are instructive. Eager’s visit to Ukraine sponsored by the Burisma-funded Atlantic Council began 12 days after the so-called whistleblower officially filed his August 12 complaint about President Donald Trump’s phone call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.

Kurt Volker, who has just resigned as the Trump Administration's special representative for Ukraine, is a senior advisor at the Atlantic Council and also heads the McCain Institute.

Max Blumenthal says that the Atlantic Council has become a "clearinghouse for legal corruption."

Update I: (from Brietbart): "Impeachment star witness William Taylor has has long relationship with Burisma-backed think tank." 

Update II: Second Schiff staff linked to Atlantic Council.

Thursday, October 3, 2019

Ex-California Gov. & China Launch Think Tank to Fight Climate Change

Here is more from Bloomberg:

Two of President Donald Trump’s biggest foils are teaming up on an issue he loves to scoff at: climate change.
Former California Governor Jerry Brown and China’s chief climate official, Xie Zhenhua, are launching a think tank to push policymakers on both sides of the Pacific to jointly develop better ways to cut greenhouse gases. A key part of the effort, based at the University of California, Berkeley, is trying to block Trump’s plan to roll back vehicle emissions standards.
Brown, a Democrat, said one of his goals for the initiative, called the California-China Climate Institute, is to push China to toughen its own vehicle emissions standards. The move, he said, would make it “very likely” that automakers continue to make low-emission vehicles even if Trump succeeds in rolling back American standards.
The initiative at Berkeley will work with government agencies in California and China, as well as the Institute of Climate Change and Sustainable Development at Tsinghua University in Beijing.

Here is a link to the think tank's new website.

Wednesday, October 2, 2019

Think Tank Quickies (#360)

  • Suspected North Korean cyber campaign targets think tanks. 
  • John Bolton slams Trump's North Korea policy at think tank CSIS.
  • Brookings among the think tanks receiving Chinese money.
  • It must be said (get the think tank's name right). 
  • Jeet Heer: In an age of policy boldness, think tanks have become timid.
  • The Nation: How far-right operatives manufactured the "crisis" of free speech with think tanks.
  • Chinese Embassy working with consultants to embrace think tanks.
  • Rocky Mountain Institute offers prize to encourage engineers to build a more efficient air conditioner.
  • ReFED: A think tank that works to reduce food waste.
  • Data & Society Research Institute: "A think/do tank in New York City dedicated to addressing social, technical, ethical, legal, and policy issues that are emerging because of data-centric technological development.”